Comparing the Effectiveness of Two Approaches of Psychoanalysis and Schema Therapy in the Treatment of Narcissistic Personality Disorder

Rahnemaee, Mohammad Jamal; Asadi, Javanshir

Volume 12 - Articles-1401 MEJDS (2022) 12: 151 | Back to browse issues page

Mendeley

Zotero

RefWorks

Rahnemaee M J, Asadi J. Comparing the Effectiveness of Two Approaches of Psychoanalysis and Schema Therapy in the Treatment of Narcissistic Personality Disorder. MEJDS 2022; 12 :151-151
URL: http://jdisabilstud.org/article-1-2214-en.html

Comparing the Effectiveness of Two Approaches of Psychoanalysis and Schema Therapy in the Treatment of Narcissistic Personality Disorder

Mohammad Jamal Rahnemaee¹

, Javanshir Asadi ^*¹

1- Department of Psychology, Gorgan Branch, Islamic Azad University

Abstract: (1471 Views)

Background & Objectives: Personality disorders are persistent patterns in the mind and behavior that do not conform to cultural norms and cause dissatisfaction and disruption of a person’s functions. Among personality disorders, narcissistic personality disorder, due to remaining in the fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, has a special diagnostic and therapeutic importance. People with this disorder arrogantly think they are very important and unique. Despite these feelings, they have fragile self–esteem and are vulnerable to even minor criticism. One of the treatments used for narcissistic personality is classical psychoanalytic treatment. An important part of the classical literature of classical psychoanalysis and the new wave of contemporary psychoanalysts have investigated this personality disorder. Another treatment used for narcissistic personality is schema therapy. Schemas are formed based on educational methods, cognitions and bodily feelings during childhood and adolescence and continue in other periods of life. Therefore, this study aimed to compare the effectiveness of schema therapy and psychoanalysis in treating narcissistic personality disorder.
Methods: The research method was quasi–experimental with a pretest–posttest design with a control group. The statistical population of the present study included all individuals referred to the Hamava Psychology Clinic and the Tehran Welfare Clinic who were diagnosed with narcissistic personality disorder in 2019. The study sample consisted of 20 patients from Hamava Clinic and 10 patients from Tehran Welfare Clinic who were diagnosed with the narcissistic disorder. The studied samples were randomly assigned to three groups: psychoanalytic group, schema therapy group, and control group. It should be noted that at the beginning of the study, 10 people were assigned to each group, and at the end of the test, three people remained in each group due to the drop in the subjects. The inclusion criteria were as follows: not receiving drug treatment and drug use, being literate in reading and writing, and providing informed consent. The exclusion criteria were as follows: not having acute mental disorders, participation in another intervention program, and absence of more than two sessions. The study data were collected in the pretest and posttest in three groups using Millon Clinical Multiaxial Inventory–III (Millon et al., 1994) and Narcissistic Personality Inventory (Raskin & Terry, 1988). The first experimental group received traditional psychoanalytic treatment. The second experimental group received schema therapy for 8 sessions, one 90–minute session per week, and the subjects in the control group did not receive any treatment. To analyze the collected data, descriptive (mean and standard deviation) and inferential statistics (univariate covariance analysis or ANCOVA) were performed in SPSS version 21 statistical software. The significance level of the tests was considered 0.05.
Results: The results showed a significant difference between the control group and the psychoanalytic treatment group in the mean scores of the variable of narcissistic personality disorder (p<0.001). While the examination of the averages in the two control and schema therapy groups (p=0.069) and the two psychoanalytic treatment and schema therapy groups (p=0.081) showed no significant difference between them. Also, the eta coefficient indicated that 76.6% of the changes in narcissistic personality disorder were due to the intervention of psychoanalytic treatment.
Conclusion: Based on the findings of this study, psychoanalytic therapy is more effective in reducing the symptoms of narcissism than schema therapy. As a result, clinicians and researchers can pay more attention to dynamic therapies in narcissistic personality disorder interventions.

Keywords: Schema therapy, Psychoanalysis, Narcissistic personality disorder

Full-Text [PDF 540 kb] (490 Downloads)

Type of Study: Original Research Article | Subject: Psychology

References

1. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 5th edition. Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Association; 2013.

2. Hickling FW, Martin J, Walcott G, Paisley V, Hutchinson N, Clarke T, et al. The creation and validation of the Jamaica Personality Disorder Inventory. West Indian Med J. 2013;62(5):389–96.‌ [DOI]

3. Skodol AE, Bender DS, Oldham JM. An alternative model for personality disorders: DSM-5 Section III and beyond. In: Oldham JM, Skodol AE, Bender DS; editors. The American psychiatric publishing textbook of personality disorders. American Psychiatric Publishing, Inc; 2014.

4. Sadock BJ, Sadock VA, Ruiz P. Kaplan & Sadock’S synopsis of psychiatry: behavioral sciences/clinical psychiatry. Philadelphia: Lippinott Wiliams and Wilkins; 2014.

5. Heinze PE, Fatfouta R, Schröder–Abé M. Validation of an implicit measure of antagonistic narcissism. J Res Pers. 2020;88:103993. [DOI]

6. Vater A, Schröder-Abé M, Ritter K, Renneberg B, Schulze L, Bosson JK, et al. The narcissistic personality inventory: a useful tool for assessing pathological narcissism? evidence from patients with narcissistic personality disorder. J Pers Assess. 2013;95(3):301–8. [DOI]

7. Skodol AE, Morey LC, Bender DS, Oldham JM. The alternative DSM–5 model for personality disorders: a clinical application. Am J Psychiatry. 2015;172(7):606–13. [DOI]

8. Majdara E, Rahimian Boogar I, Talepasand S, Gregory R J. The efficacy of dynamic deconstructive psychotherapy in treatment of borderline personality disorder: introducing an evidence-based therapeutic model. Studis in Medical Sciences. 2018;29(6):1–19. [Persian] [Article]

9. Khorianian M, Heidarinasab L, Tabibi Z, Agha Mohammadian Sherbaf HR. Effectiveness of intensive short-term dynamic psychotherapy in decreasing the symptoms of depression and increasing emotional disclosure in patients suffering from depression. Thoughts & Behavior in Clinical Psychology. 2013;7(26):37–46. [Persian] [Article]

10. Taghavi F, Mirzaie P, Azandariani M, Rezaei Shojaei S. The effectiveness of short-term dynamic psychotherapy on anxiety, depression and happiness in women with generalized anxiety. Medical Journal of Mashhad University of Medical Sciences. 2020;62(Special Issue):456–66. [Persian] [Article]

11. Moradzadeh Khorasani L, Mirzaian B, Hassanzadeh R. The effectiveness of intensive short-term dynamic psychotherapy on mentalization in non-suicidal self-injurious people. Iranian Journal of Psychiatric Nursing. 2020;8(3):22–35. [Persian] [Article]

12. Benecke C, Huber D, Staats H, Zimmermann J, Henkel M, Deserno H, et al. A comparison of psychoanalytic therapy and cognitive behavioral therapy for anxiety (panic–agoraphobia) and personality disorders (APD study): presentation of the RCT study design. Z Psychosom Med Psychother. 2016;62(3):252–69. [DOI]

13. Diamond D, Yeomans F, Levy KN. Psychodynamic psychotherapy for narcissistic personality. In: Campbell WK, Miller JD; editors. The handbook of narcissism and narcissistic personality disorder: theoretical approaches, empirical findings, and treatments. John Wiley & Sons, Inc; 2011.

14. Rashn Sh, Makvand-Hosseini Sh, Rezaei AM, Tabatabaee SM. The effect of long-term dynamic psychotherapy on the personality structure of patients with dependent personality disorder. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 2018;9(4):1–12. [Persian] [Article]

15. Young J, Behary WT. Schema-focused therapy for personality disorders. In: Terrier N, Wells A, Haddock G; editors. Treating complex cases: the cognitive behavioural therapy approach. John Wiley & Sons, Inc;1998.

16. Lobbestael J, Van Vreeswijk M, Spinhoven P, Schouten E, Arntz A. Reliability and validity of the Short Schema Mode Inventory (SMI). Behav Cogn Psychother. 2010;38(4):437–58. [DOI]

17. Rahimaghaee F, Hatamipour K, Ashoori J. The effect of group schema therapy on symptoms of depression and increase quality of life among nurses. Journal of Nursing Education. 2017;6(3):17–23. [Persian] [DOI]

18. Stopa L, Waters A. The effect of mood on responses to the Young Schema Questionnaire: short form. Psychol Psychother. 2005;78(1):45–57. [DOI]

19. Rezaei F. Tarhvare darmani dar afsordegi mozmen (hamrah ba chekide maghalat dahomin hamayesh peyapey salianeye anjoman elmi ravan pezeshkan Iran) [Schema-focused therapy and chronic depression]. Iranian Journal of Psychiatry and Clinical Psychology. 2010;16(3):387. [Persian]

20. Dickhaut V, Arntz A. Combined group and individual schema therapy for borderline personality disorder: a pilot study. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry. 2014;45(2):242–51.‌ [DOI]

21. Malogiannis IA, Arntz A, Spyropoulou A, Tsartsara E, Aggeli A, Karveli S, et al. Schema therapy for patients with chronic depression: a single case series study. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry. 2014;45(3):319–29. [DOI]

22. Yarmohamadi Vasel M, Borjali A, Golzari M, Delavar A. The effect of schema therapy in patients with recurrent depression disorder: a single-case study. Culture Counseling. 2013;3(12):21–48. [Persian] [Article]

23. Khodabandelow S, Najafi M, Rahimian-Boogar I. The effectiveness of schema mode therapy on reducing the narcissism's symptoms in narcissistic personality disorder: a single-subject research. J Res Behav Sci. 2017;15(3):321–30. [Persian] [Article]

24. Delavar A. Ravesh haye tahghigh dar ravan shenasi va oloome tarbiati [Research methods in psychology and educational sciences]. Tehran: Payame Noor University; 2006.

25. Millon T, Millon C, Davis R, Grossman S. Millon Clinical Multiaxial Inventory-III. Pearson; 1994.

26. Chegini M, Delavar A, Garrayi B. Vizhegi haye ravan sanji porseshname balini chand mehvari Millon–3 [Psychometric characteristics of Millon Clinical Multiaxial Inventory-III]. Modern Psychological Research. 2013;8(29):135–62. [Persian]

27. Raskin R, Terry H. A principal-components analysis of the Narcissistic Personality Inventory and further evidence of its construct validity. J Pers Soc Psychol. 1988;54(5):890–902. [DOI]

28. Edelstein RS, Yim IS, Quas JA. Narcissism predicts heightened cortisol reactivity to a psychosocial stressor in men. J Res Pers. 2010;44(5):565–72. [DOI]

29. Zeini Hasanvand N, Javanmard K, Goodarzi M. Validation of The Narcissistic Personality Inventory–40. Journal of Psychology. 2015;19(1):102–18. [Persian]

30. Young JE. Cognitive therapy for personality disorders: a schema-focused approach. Sarasota, FL: Professional Resource Exchange; 1990.

31. Baljé A, Greeven A, van Giezen A, Korrelboom K, Arntz A, Spinhoven P. Group schema therapy versus group cognitive behavioral therapy for social anxiety disorder with comorbid avoidant personality disorder: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial. Trials. 2016;17(1):487. [DOI]

32. Shah Hosseini Tazik S, Zamani Zarchi MS. Asar bakhshiye tarkib darman haye shenakhti-raftari (CBT) va ravan pooyeshi dar tadile sefat mokharreb ekhtelal shakhsiat vabaste [The effectiveness of the combination of cognitive-behavioral therapies (CBT) and psychodynamics in modifying the destructive traits of dependent personality disorder]. In: International Conference on Humanities, Psychology and Social Sciences [Internet]. Tehran; 2015. [Persian] [Article]

33. Carsky M. Supportive psychoanalytic therapy for personality disorders. Psychotherapy (Chic). 2013;50(3):443–8. [DOI]

34. Rorie K. Psychodynamic psychotherapy for personality disorders: a systematic review. [Thesis for MSc]. [US]: St Catherine University; 2016.

35. Cramer P. Personality, personality disorders, and defense mechanisms. J Pers. 1999;67(3):535–54. [DOI]

36. Di Giuseppe M, Gennaro A, Lingiardi V, Perry JC. The role of defense mechanisms in emerging personality disorders in clinical adolescents. Psychiatry. 2019;82(2):128–42. [DOI]

37. Freud A. The ego and the mechanisms of defence. London: Routledge; 2018.

38. Taubner S, Volkert J. Evidence-based psychodynamic therapies for the treatment of patients with borderline personality disorder. Clin Psychol Eur. 2019;1(2):e30639. [DOI]

39. Thimm JC. Mediation of early maladaptive schemas between perceptions of parental rearing style and personality disorder symptoms. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry. 2010;41(1):52–9. [DOI]

40. Dieckmann E, Behary W. Schema therapy: an approach for treating narcissistic personality disorder. Fortschr Neurol Psychiatr. 2015;83:463-77.

41. Behary WT, Dieckmann E. Schema therapy for narcissism: the art of empathic confrontation, limit-setting, and leverage. In: Campbell WK, Miller JD; editors. The handbook of narcissism and narcissistic personality disorder. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, Inc; 2012. [DOI]